"Phantom Picnic"
That is one adorable little stuffed animal.
It’s rather amusing to me how the more I watch this, the more ridiculous it seems to get. Yet despite the preposterous nature of it all, the whimsical atmosphere is somewhat infectious, and the mystery is no less compelling for it. The characters are still my least favorite part of Karneval, but there’s a few steps gained in the right direction this week, which is always a plus. Plot-wise, however, things are as busy as always, and not at all ready to make sense yet.
Gareki and Nai’s relationship seems to have upped the ante on several levels, and Nai’s already gotten attached enough that when Karoku speaks to him in a dream and warns him to let Gareki go before it’s too late, Nai pulls a classic shoujo heroine stunt and literally pushes his friend away for the sake of keeping him safe. To be honest, this whole little drama feels rather forced, but it does make more sense once Nai’s true nature is revealed. As I’d thought previously, those tufts of hair do look an awful lot like animal ears, and for good reason; Nai is a human/animal hybrid, thought to be created by this mysterious Karoku from a rabbit-like species known as Niji. His bizarre behavior up til now suddenly makes all that much more sense, though why he was created or made to leave the Niji Forest is still as great a mystery as his identity has been all this time.
This does, however, change the dynamic between Gareki and Nai somewhat. While Gareki previously looked on Nai as some sort naive child that needed help, he now looks exactly like a pet to him (though there may just be more to this than a simple attachment to a fluffy little animal, in my humble opinion), and he’s somewhat pleased to think that Karoku has picked a fight with him. It all points to the fact that despite his tough guy facade, Gareki considers Nai as more than just some random obstacle, and he’s willing to stick around with him and Circus to find out more.
As to Circus itself, we’re introduced to several more of it’s members this week. The somewhat intimidating doctor Akari (Hirakawa Daisuke) is first on the lineup, though we also get a quick look at Kiichi (Kitamura Eri) and Jiki (Nakamura Yuuichi), both of whom remain as much a stylish mystery as everyone else. It’s still not completely clear what it is that Circus is really after, but they’re certainly interested in Nai’s origins and in Karoku’s role in all of this, which seems to be linked to this mysterious antagonist organization we were told about last week.
It seems that for every mystery we delve into, we’re handed yet another handful of questions. Though we now have an explanation for Nai’s character, we still know next to nothing about almost everyone else except Gareki (who seems to have quite the traumatic past) and the intrigue of this strange and boisterous world remains shrouded in shadows. Just why do Circus and the anti-organization exist in the first place? Why would Karoku create Nai, and what is his purpose in doing so? How exactly did Gareki find himself in the right place at the right time and end up wrapped up in everything? Just what the holy Triforce is going on?
I don’t have any answers, but I do know one thing: this is definitely a weirdly interesting little anime we’ve got our hands on here.
Gareki and Nai’s relationship seems to have upped the ante on several levels, and Nai’s already gotten attached enough that when Karoku speaks to him in a dream and warns him to let Gareki go before it’s too late, Nai pulls a classic shoujo heroine stunt and literally pushes his friend away for the sake of keeping him safe. To be honest, this whole little drama feels rather forced, but it does make more sense once Nai’s true nature is revealed. As I’d thought previously, those tufts of hair do look an awful lot like animal ears, and for good reason; Nai is a human/animal hybrid, thought to be created by this mysterious Karoku from a rabbit-like species known as Niji. His bizarre behavior up til now suddenly makes all that much more sense, though why he was created or made to leave the Niji Forest is still as great a mystery as his identity has been all this time.
This does, however, change the dynamic between Gareki and Nai somewhat. While Gareki previously looked on Nai as some sort naive child that needed help, he now looks exactly like a pet to him (though there may just be more to this than a simple attachment to a fluffy little animal, in my humble opinion), and he’s somewhat pleased to think that Karoku has picked a fight with him. It all points to the fact that despite his tough guy facade, Gareki considers Nai as more than just some random obstacle, and he’s willing to stick around with him and Circus to find out more.
As to Circus itself, we’re introduced to several more of it’s members this week. The somewhat intimidating doctor Akari (Hirakawa Daisuke) is first on the lineup, though we also get a quick look at Kiichi (Kitamura Eri) and Jiki (Nakamura Yuuichi), both of whom remain as much a stylish mystery as everyone else. It’s still not completely clear what it is that Circus is really after, but they’re certainly interested in Nai’s origins and in Karoku’s role in all of this, which seems to be linked to this mysterious antagonist organization we were told about last week.
It seems that for every mystery we delve into, we’re handed yet another handful of questions. Though we now have an explanation for Nai’s character, we still know next to nothing about almost everyone else except Gareki (who seems to have quite the traumatic past) and the intrigue of this strange and boisterous world remains shrouded in shadows. Just why do Circus and the anti-organization exist in the first place? Why would Karoku create Nai, and what is his purpose in doing so? How exactly did Gareki find himself in the right place at the right time and end up wrapped up in everything? Just what the holy Triforce is going on?
I don’t have any answers, but I do know one thing: this is definitely a weirdly interesting little anime we’ve got our hands on here.
Nice review, Kairi! I am on the same boat as you with the questions--they just keep on coming! But I hope that soon we'll get some answers because it's getting hard to keep track of everything/everybody, especially since most of the characters are kind of 2D at the moment except Gareki, whom I like as a lead. I'm wary of having all the glamour and far-reaching mysteries/situations, because Robotics:Notes did the same thing ( with less glamour, although they had way better character development for the main cast) and then fell short on the series conclusion. That was disappointing, even though I really loved R:N (kai x aki ftw!) xD
ReplyDeleteAnd cute animals...I'm such a sucker for cute animals. :3
I'm glad you enjoyed it! Though I just noticed I forgot some editing for the LoQ version...
DeleteIn any case, I'm really enjoying the craziness of the series, though as you say it's getting harder and harder to remember who's doing what and why. I think Gareki probably is the protagonist rather than Nai, but he was introduced differently, which is interesting. I haven't seen R;N, but I did hear this was a problem. Hopefully Karneval manages to avoid that trap, but in twelve episodes there's all that much room for issues.
Who isn't?? D: If they're small and fluffy, I WANT ONE. :3
Sooooo cutee!! Nai is the cutest animal! lol. I'm also enjoying the craziness of this series, I just hope the finale isn't a dud.
ReplyDeleteAlso, Kairi, I meant to ask this as soon as I saw complaints but why is it so hard for you guys to take the voice actor behind Nai seriously? I do not follow the seiyuu's as earnestly as everyone else I'm afraid so I don't quite understand, would you mind explaining this to me? Thanks!
He is quite adorable haha. I guess we'll find out whether or not this will work out soon enough.
DeleteHmm, well it's not that he's a bad seiyuu or anything, but he's a much older voice actor playing the role of a little lost boy, and occasionally the acting falls flat. For example, in the second episode when Gareki was about to be shot and Nai calls out his name, it didn't feel very real. It just sounded like he was reading off a script rather than acting. For me at least, he doesn't feel like a seamless choice of an actor. Does that help? :)
Ahhh, I understand a little better with that example. It seems fine to me, but then I never was one to care about the voice behind the character until recently. It will take a while before I can give an accurate critique over the choice of a voice actor. Anyways, great review Kairi and see you next week!
ReplyDeleteTo be honest, if it works for you that's great! I never used to be bogged down my actors myself, but after a while certain actors pop up so much and sound so off in certain roles that it's hard to ignore. At least, this was the case for me.
DeleteThanks, I hope you enjoyed reading it! See you in a week. ^^
It feels like D.Gray-Man with a shojo flair...>>..and spiced up with No.6 Shion-Nezumi dynamic. Well, not quite, but there are definitely similarities. Now Nai is revealed to be a hybrid, I'm less concerned with him being a well-rounded character that can stand his own. I have to admit, it seems like a pretty convenient excuse for his naivete...and possibly lack of character depth, but I don't think it makes this show less charming. I guess it's just a very easy show to enjoy without having to engage in some philosophical debate that many shows seem to like to launch into these days.
ReplyDeleteI'm also one of the obtuse individuals when it comes to voice actors...heh. I don't think I've ever had the experience where a voice performance is so jarring it's enough to rock me out of the moment, save for dubs, but that's a whole other discussion. I can actually identify quite a few voices, but again, I'm not a critic, even Nai isn't a big issue for me on the technical plane. If anything, I just don't really like his deliberate squeaky voice period, and in that regard, I do believe Shimono isn't the best choice.
Ive not yet seen either of those, though I mean to soon. =x It is rather convenient, but at the same time it was probably the author's intention to have him be an animal from the beginning so it makes sense for now. Really though, good fun is always nice regardless of what you can say about a series.
DeleteI usually don't have too much of an issue; I can take most voices perfectly fine (dubs are... different, yes) but occasionally one pops up that I just can't take seriously.
Speaking of dubs.....what's your thought on Renton's dub?
DeleteRenton specifically? Uhm, I prefer Yuko Sanpei by a lot, though Johnny Young Bosch is okay I guess. >_> I can't take him as seriously though.
DeleteI always thought his voice was too old for Renton...=/..I think he was better as Lelouch, but Renton was really off for me.
DeleteI agree, but I have issues with dubs in general. I feel like, as a trend, VAs are more concerned with getting the lines correct rather than inputting emotion. That's not to say there aren't good ones out there, or that certain roles don't feel natural, but for the most part I'm usually better able to connect to seiyuu.
Delete