Let's break most of the current stereotypes about anime, shall we?
Zetsuen no Tempest is a strange little creature of an anime. Even after just a mere seven years of being part of the anime community, I can sense something different about this series, something I've been missing ardently over the last few years without even being aware of it. It's not something we normally think about, the general trends of the industry that is, until something like this comes along and forces us to take a closer look.
There's no doubt that we are currently in the era of the slice of life series, the era of the romantic comedy and light novel adaptations that make up the majority of anime produced every season. Adventure and action are not gone, but there only ever seems to be a handful of them compared to everything else that goes on every twelve weeks or so. Yet this was not always the case; at least, when I started watching anime, things were the other way around. Everyone watched battle and adventure series first and comedies second, and grand projects on the scale of Zetsuen were not rare beasts to be gawked at. That doesn't mean those particular series were better than what we have now, but I do have to say that I miss the fantastical aspects of that time in my life, something anime had a large part in.
Even though that's the case, I still feel that Zetsuen isn't easily classified as a series referencing a past now gone or a show that's trying to bring that trend back. After all, this isn't exactly your conventional action series, seeing as it's at its most intense when no one moves an inch. This is its own experiment, its own production, and I'd be damned if I said I didn't love it.
On paper, Zetsuen probably doesn't sound all that appealing. It's a series so theatrical that it quotes Shakespeare in every episode, boasts an orchestral score, and utilizes every bit of Bones' intense dramatic flair, which, for some, is just a bit too over the top in theory. Even after trying the first few episodes out, this was a series I liked but didn't love; in fact, for the first half of the first season, I tended to forget it existed until I saw it updated every Thursday afternoon. It just wasn't something I particularly saw myself being excited to watch, even if it was a Bones production. Yet somehow, without my even noticing it, I found myself captivated little by little, to the point where this became one of my most anticipated series of the Fall and Winter seasons, second only to Shinsekai Yori .
Certainly, the flair is part of what distinguishes this series from its contemporaries, but there's much more to it than that. This is theatricality in all earnestness; it's not just a reference to Shakespeare and drama, it is a play, an opera, a performance in animated form that acknowledges this fact. It somehow manages to take itself deadly seriously while not taking itself seriously at all, and it is a tragedy and comedy in equal measures. It is grandiose and awe-inspiring, funny and tongue-in-cheek, and Bones through and through despite being a manga adaptation. In fact, I think this is a series that could only be brought to life by the Bones touch, because no other studio is as ridiculously fabulous and dramatic as they are, nor does anyone take flair so seriously. Presentation matters, and I think Bones gets that, though it's hard for them to find the perfect project to pull it off, and it seems that Zetsuen may just be exactly what they needed.
Even the themes are huge and all-encompassing. Fate, the role of individuals in the world, grief and coming to terms with tragedy; it's all in there and very much at the center of everything. From Aika to Mahiro to Hanemura, everyone has a role to play, a purpose to fill, but they're all still themselves, with their individual choices inducing a butterfly effect upon the entire planet. In fact, it's those individuals that hold the most power whether dead or alive. Aika's effect on Yoshino and Mahiro, Hakaze's unrequited love for Yoshino, even Hanemura's desire to save the world for the sake of winning his girlfriend back; the power of these relationships overcomes even the sway of reason and logic. One does not save the world for the saintly justification of saving humanity as a whole; one saves the world for their loved ones, because, as Hakaze so smugly points out, it's better to do something for someone rather than something.
The more I write and think about this series, the more I feel conflicted about letting it go. There's just nothing quite like this series, at least not in recent memory. It's not so much about the experience as a whole, but in the little moments where I was won over. Watching that four or five episode debate with Samon striking his sword and making priceless expressions... Hanemura proving himself the least foolish among a group of fools trying to figure out the identity of Yoshino's girlfriend... Jun trucking a suitcase of porn off to the final battle... Aika trolling Yoshino and Mahiro to the very end... There's just no way for me to put my feelings into words. It's like waving goodbye to some very dear friends, or, more appropriately, like watching the curtain come down on my favorite opera. Though I know objectively that the performance is over, my heart waits wistfully for the next time I'll be able to see this story unfold, and that, I think, marks just how special an experience it has been. You don't need perfection or new ideas to achieve a wonderful result, just some actors, a stage, and the ambition to pull it all together as dramatically as possible.
"It somehow manages to take itself deadly seriously while not taking itself seriously at all, and it is a tragedy and comedy in equal measures."
ReplyDeleteBeautifully put, couldn't have said it better myself. I can just imagine the producers sitting behind their desk and grinning at our sorry attempts at piecing together the story when it was just in its earlier stage. I mean like seriously, for perhaps the first time ever, I feel totally happy for being trolled lol....
It was so much fun speculating at every turn but only to be proven wrong later on. Most of us thought Hanemura's GF had some role to play, but damn....she turned out to be the biggest red herring of the year. We don't even see her face! LOL You know what's funny, I was so ready to crank my neck and turn the camera around..
I agree with you that the industry is saturated with shows that pander but don't inspire, so it's such a bless when studios go out of their way to show they still care about quality even when they are not rewarded in the form of commercial success.
There was so much speculation, even among the characters themselves, that it was impossible to tell what was truth and what was meant to throw us off. Aika's identity, her killer, Hanemura's girlfriend, the Mage of Exodus; it was all really hard to keep track of, but it was incredibly fun. I love theorizing, and Bones makes it really interesting to do. AO was like this as well. I was so sure she was going to turn out to be Aika. xD
DeleteIt's not like I hate those series either, but they're just not my thing. It'd be nice if there was more of a balance, but studios have to stay afloat one way or another I suppose, and they're driven by demand.
Bones is one of the only studios who doesn't give a rat's ass about conventions, they try to revolutionize the industry rather than being revolutionized by it.
DeleteIn all honesty, I'm not a big fan of those types either, not because I hate the genres per se, but there really aren't many strong series from that stock. Also, it's so much easier to pander with those series because no matter how overrun they are with tropes, there is always the niche fandom who will buy the stuff. Even Madhouse needs to cater to pressure these days, and let's face it...despite being the one studio loved by all anime critics, it really doesn't do well financially.
I wouldn't say that they're completely free of conventions, but they do take far more creative risk than any other studio currently does. I have a feeling they probably enjoy their projects a hell of a lot more than most as well.
DeleteThere's just not much innovation going on there, or anything too interesting. Studios are afraid to go the way of Shinsekai Yori, which tanked so horribly it's painful to think about. I just can't do the looks over substance thing; no matter how pretty the girl or hot the bishounen, it's not worth it if there's nothing beneath the surface. Which is why Amnesia was so bad; I could have cared less about the bishounen, as long as they were interesting or well fleshed out, which they weren't (not by a HUGE long shot). Critics and casual viewers have different priorities, after all.
Well, convention is not a bad thing really, only when the staff behind a project shows no sign of effort to challenge it in some way that it becomes a problem. I think Soul Eater, Ouran and even FMA all have conventional elements characteristic of their respective genre, but there were also things that set them apart. So yeah, I guess it takes talent to pick out source material.
DeleteOh....Amnesia..I still have a hard time believing it's adapted by Brainsbase, the studio with one of the better track records out there. At least Hakuoki from a few seasons back had a decent plot, Amnesia just falls completely flat, like wow I don't think the girl could have gotten more passive even if she tried, and I have some serious issues with such female leads. It's truly depressing that SSY doesn't get the recognition it deserves, and honestly, it's not even a very difficult show to digest if you stayed for the whole ride. I'd understanding if something like Tatami Galaxy (which is absurdly inspiring, but hard to follow) doesn't sell for being overly artsy and abstract...but SSY..it still baffles me why it's so underrated in Japan.
I don't think it's a bad thing either, but I like seeing them challenged once in a while. You can't get rid of it completely since all stories take elements from others. Plus they add the small element of familiarity that draws most people in.
DeleteWhat upset me most about that was that Kaori Nazuka got the lead role. She's an amazingly emotional actress when given the chance, but she had to be completely boring and flat for this role, and that's what she's going to be remembered for for a while. Shoujo-stereotype heroines are annoying as it is, but this one was hardly even a person; she was like an accessory to various bishounen. I don't understand either, or how Shinsekai lost out to Amnesia. It's baffling to me.
Oh yeah, she voiced Eureka didn't she? I absolutely loved her performance for the role. It's all the more degrading when our main character doesn't even get a name.....or maybe she does at the end but I didn't bother to stick around.
DeleteAnd ouch...it's news to me that it did better than SSY. Then again, when SAO was the hype of its day, I couldn't quite wrap my head around it either. It wasn't a bad show, but I didn't think it was anything groundbreaking either, so the insane, almost cult popularity came as a surprise to me. So I suppose it won't be the first time or the last time that quality and commercial success don't correlate.
She did, and she's my favorite seiyuu. I wasn't so bothered by the name, but the lack of personality was pretty insulting. She doesn't.
DeleteIt did, and it was shocking. SAO is a mystery to me too, but at least it wasn't as boring as Amnesia turned out. It still wasn't so great that I'd justify the fanaticism, but hey, people are free to like what they want. It'd be nice if series as good as SSY got more attention though.