"Calm Day"
Only Pinion would look at a futuristic super-robot and think “barbecue”.
I feel like with every passing episode, Suisei no Gargantia continues to prove just how beautiful a work it really is. This week’s episode wasn’t nearly as philosophical or down to earth as the last couple have been, but it nevertheless did much to paint Ledo’s predicament in a fairly down-to-earth manner. I suppose if you wanted to, you could designate this episode “the fanservice-ridden beach episode”, and you wouldn’t be wrong (despite the lack of a real beach), but there’s still a fundamentally realist core at the center of all the swimsuits and transvestite interest in our unlucky protagonist.
To start with, while becoming an accepted member of Gargantia is all well and good, Ledo still hasn’t found any real purpose in his staying there. Namely, he’d like a job, something where he’d be a contributing force to the fleet’s needs rather than just another mouth to feed. Of course, finding a job isn’t as easy as snapping your fingers and declaring you’ll get one; it requires effort, time, and most of all, luck. Like any job market, there just aren’t positions for anything Ledo considers taking on (except clearing manure, which he can’t even stand for longer than a first whiff of the stuff), and this is a universal issue for all soldiers who leave the front lines. Just what kind of work should you take on after all that time at war? As Chamber constantly repeats, there are simply no jobs suited for Ledo’s uniquely acquired military skills, and unfortunately that means Ledo still hasn’t found a place to feel fulfilled while among the Gargantians.
However, there’s more to life than just work, and though Ledo and Chamber may not understand this (“I repeat: What is the significance of this?”), it’s at the center of more or less everything the Gargantians have to offer him. Throwing a party, having a barbecue, racing gliders, and running from some very persistent would-be employers don’t necessarily serve any greater purpose, but as Bevel explained last week, sometimes you don’t really need one. With every passing day on Earth, Ledo becomes more open to the idea of life as a journey rather than a destination, and slowly but surely his perspective on his own existence continues to evolve beyond the narrowed mindset of a soldier.
If there’s one thing that struck a particularly bad chord with me this episode, however, it was the girls. Amy and her friends have always acted as the genki eye-candy (though Amy has far more depth than the other two), but one particular conversation this week really bothered me. When the three girls discuss body image, Melty essentially makes the point that she and the others have to watch their figures for the sake of getting boys to like them, rather than because they want to. Call me an annoying feminist or whatever you like, but whether you’re a boy or a girl, skinny, round, square, or triangular, you should never base your self-image on what anyone but you yourself want. If you change yourself for the sake of someone else, you’re objectifying yourself (and yes, I’m speaking to you boys too) and that’s just not okay. By all means, change yourself, but do it because it’s something you really truly want for yourself. That aside, however, Suisei remains my favorite offering of the season, and this episode goes a long way to prove that it can be just as funny as it is intelligent.
To start with, while becoming an accepted member of Gargantia is all well and good, Ledo still hasn’t found any real purpose in his staying there. Namely, he’d like a job, something where he’d be a contributing force to the fleet’s needs rather than just another mouth to feed. Of course, finding a job isn’t as easy as snapping your fingers and declaring you’ll get one; it requires effort, time, and most of all, luck. Like any job market, there just aren’t positions for anything Ledo considers taking on (except clearing manure, which he can’t even stand for longer than a first whiff of the stuff), and this is a universal issue for all soldiers who leave the front lines. Just what kind of work should you take on after all that time at war? As Chamber constantly repeats, there are simply no jobs suited for Ledo’s uniquely acquired military skills, and unfortunately that means Ledo still hasn’t found a place to feel fulfilled while among the Gargantians.
However, there’s more to life than just work, and though Ledo and Chamber may not understand this (“I repeat: What is the significance of this?”), it’s at the center of more or less everything the Gargantians have to offer him. Throwing a party, having a barbecue, racing gliders, and running from some very persistent would-be employers don’t necessarily serve any greater purpose, but as Bevel explained last week, sometimes you don’t really need one. With every passing day on Earth, Ledo becomes more open to the idea of life as a journey rather than a destination, and slowly but surely his perspective on his own existence continues to evolve beyond the narrowed mindset of a soldier.
If there’s one thing that struck a particularly bad chord with me this episode, however, it was the girls. Amy and her friends have always acted as the genki eye-candy (though Amy has far more depth than the other two), but one particular conversation this week really bothered me. When the three girls discuss body image, Melty essentially makes the point that she and the others have to watch their figures for the sake of getting boys to like them, rather than because they want to. Call me an annoying feminist or whatever you like, but whether you’re a boy or a girl, skinny, round, square, or triangular, you should never base your self-image on what anyone but you yourself want. If you change yourself for the sake of someone else, you’re objectifying yourself (and yes, I’m speaking to you boys too) and that’s just not okay. By all means, change yourself, but do it because it’s something you really truly want for yourself. That aside, however, Suisei remains my favorite offering of the season, and this episode goes a long way to prove that it can be just as funny as it is intelligent.
Witnessing Ledo's endeavor spilled on an endless sequence of job hunts, swimming lessons and errands was certainly entertaining. To boot, this episode simply makes the splendor of Gargantia as a floating society more phenomenal. It would be great if the series later reveals how mankind managed to survive the ice age and begin from scratch which is deemed implausible to begin with.
ReplyDeleteAs a fan-service episode this had been pretty decent, but considering Gen's influence as this series' writer, I'm a bit concerned about how much he dampened. In spite of that though, SnG still undoubtedly stands as one of the strongest offerings this Spring season.
Also, it fascinates me how you pointed out the erroneous perspectives of both genders regarding the fundamental point of obtaining one's affection. Indeed, any effort on changing ourselves for someone else's amusement is downright otiose. We are essentially the same as human beings. We must live steering the helms of our own ships not others'. (Like hell would I want to abandon my ship.) :D
I thought it was entertaining, but it unfortunately wasn't up to the spectacular caliber of the first for episodes. I really appreciated the laugh factor (I've been having a bad weekend) and I still think it was a pretty decent episode, but it could have been better, I'm sure. I did enjoy that factor about a floating society (I always do), but in terms of Urobuchi, he hasn't been as hands on with Gargantia as usual. The director has had plenty of experience with this type of show, so it may be that that's what's keeping Gen's usual style at bay.
DeleteI really think it's really sad that both girls and boys think things like "If I'm skinny/buff/a certain style I'll be loved". It's okay to want to be something, but for your own self-esteem and not because you want to live up to someone's expectations. I'm glad you think so as well, because it's really depressing to see this all over the place.
While this episode was lighter on the philosophical side compared to the previous 4, it still was quite entertaining.
ReplyDeleteI agree in your review on the body image, however its a pretty common trait among teenage anime/manga characters thats more character centric than action centric. For example, in Toradora (while a fantastic representation of the Chinese Folklore love story of the Dragon and Tiger in which placed it in my top ten Japanese animations of all time), a few of the characters would spasm about their purpose in high school is to find a "mate" and that what makes the teenage high school experience. And it's not a common trait that is just in manga/anime. I've seen it all too often with actual people as well. Not knowing that you cannot be happy with anything until you are first happy with yourself introspectively.
However, i did enjoy ep. 5 very much spite that. And overly buff, overly-affectionate cross-dressers always makes for a good laugh at the expense of the main character. Also, i was glad to see a redeeming quality in Chamber. I never really felt that Chamber fit in with the whole environment (however this being completely intentional), it was nice to see that Chamber was making an effort also to fit in. And the gags centered around him, really fit in with everything.
Also its good to have a fun break from all the heavy philosophical and psychological aspects Suisei no Gargantia focuses on.
K.S.
I don't deny it was entertaining, because it did get some smiles and laughs out of me, but it really could have been better even then (and the humor could have been better too). Course, I enjoyed it anyway so that's just me being a wishful thinker.
DeleteI'm not saying this is an issue only visible in Gargantia; I'm of firm belief that when something bothers you, you should speak up about it, so I do. When I see this sort of portrayal happen elsewhere and I notice it, I speak up about it there too. In ignoring the issue we're accepting it, and for me that's a terrible thing.
I was actually a little bothered by the transvestite thing, Ledo's facial expressions were priceless, but the actual depiction did feel really nasty when I gave it more thought. Chamber, however, is hilarious, and I did find his little predicament to be the best part of the episode.
A fun break is good, yes. I just wish it could have been fun without having these little details hurt it.
Hope your week goes better this week, Kairi!
ReplyDeleteI adore Chamber, and any scenes he/it is in just gets 10x better! I wish I had a giant robot to bbq on and to be my constant companion...hehe
But I was kind of confused about the transvestite part of the episode. I didn't really understand what kind of statement they were trying to make, or if they were just trying to make it funny (in which case, they didn't succeed for me cause I just got kind of creeped out xD). I thought (surprisingly) that this was one of the more tolerable "beach episodes" I've seen. Maybe because of Chamber. :)
Thanks a lot Aerie! I'm feeling better today so I'm having one of those days where I do nothing but listen to music and sing. :)
DeleteChamber is great, haha. "What is the significance of this?"
I think they were trying to be funny, but it ultimately comes off as homophobic and rather cruel, so while I got a kick out of Ledo's facial expressions, I didn't at all like the depiction.
I agree, it was decently tolerable, but I think Gargantia can do better. We'll see what happens from here on out.